Hereos/Villains of each season

Who were the heroes and villains of each season? I'll do Costa Rica and then we can debate, and everyone else should do their season as well.

GUATUSO:
Julie - n/a. She was an inconsequential/inactive boot.
Dolly - HERO. Really sweet during her whole time in the game. Whatever awful traits she had were well-hidden.
John - VILLAIN. Does this even need explanation?
Brook - VILLAIN. Flipped on John, and of course there's the Loser's Lodge.
Chris - VILLAIN. Sneaky player, lied/threw Ami under the bus at the swap.
Mia - VILLAIN. I was ready to turn on Ami pre-merge and Tom early on post-merge. Fought with the Chorotegans/Chad in Ponderosa.
Chad - HERO. Poured his heart and soul into the game.
Ami - HERO. Kept cool and was very calm, remained loyal but still played for herself.
Lisa - HERO. Self explanatory.

CHOROTEGA:
Jeff - HERO. Stood up to Gregg in the first episode, took the fall for being in a different timezone. (This is kind of a stretch.)
Wanda - n/a. Was Wanda ever really relevant? One of the few inconsequential boots.
Caryn - VILLAIN. Bitchy, stand-offish and didn't talk to anyone.
Jolanda - HERO. Hot Tamale! Leader of her alliance, and even though she told people they were going next, she was still a hero IMO.
Gregg - VILLAIN. More of a Tyson-style villain.
Ibe - HERO. Funny and loyal, didn't do anything to piss anyone off.
Tom - HERO. Tom flipped a lot, but I think he was a hero anyways.
Booby Jaundice - VILLAIN. Self explanatory.
Kim - HERO. Played a GREAT game down the middle. Likeable and had a great underdog story.



Here's how I would rank all the villains together and all the heroes together.

VILLAINS:
John
Booby Jaundice
Brook
Mia
Chris
Brook
Gregg

HEROES:
Ami
Kim
Lisa
Ibe
Chad
Jolanda
Tom
Dolly
Jeff

I'm interested to see where Jeff, Helen, and Brenda weigh in on this. And I'd love to hear about Greece/Refuge/Malaysia especially.

Wow, idk about a lot of those. Tom in particular started out Hero yes, but was certainly a villain by endgame. Chad and Kim both had villainous sides to them too in that murky middle ground play..

I could put in a good argument for Brook being heroic in his actions in trying to stand up for Dolly. Was his flip revenge or retribution like?

idk where to start with the other Seasons. I would lke to think we were the heroic underdogs in Refuge, but the majority dubbed us;

(PS Vote for us in the orgies :P )

So does that mean we're evil now? It's all perspective. Same in Malaysia. I could tell you of our heroic stand against liars & sneakiness, while Chaste will tell you how we ran him out of the tribe :shrug History gets written by the winners ykwim?

I was the hero of Greece.

I am also a hero.

REFUGE

CATALIE: VILLAIN
ALINA: VILLAIN
LISI: VILLAIN
YUL: VILLAIN
KATIE: VILLAIN
ERINN: VILLAIN
BRENDA: VILLAIN
MONICA: VILLAIN
NAONKA: HERO

PREMERGE
CORINNE: VILLAIN
TYSON: VILLAIN

I was the hero of Greece.

I didnt know your name was Penny.

Who were the heroes and villains of each season? I'll do Costa Rica and then we can debate, and everyone else should do their season as well.

GUATUSO:
Julie - n/a. She was an inconsequential/inactive boot.
Dolly - HERO. Really sweet during her whole time in the game. Whatever awful traits she had were well-hidden.
John - VILLAIN. Does this even need explanation?
Brook - VILLAIN. Flipped on John, and of course there's the Loser's Lodge.
Chris - VILLAIN. Sneaky player, lied/threw Ami under the bus at the swap.
Mia - VILLAIN. I was ready to turn on Ami pre-merge and Tom early on post-merge. Fought with the Chorotegans/Chad in Ponderosa.
Chad - HERO. Poured his heart and soul into the game.
Ami - HERO. Kept cool and was very calm, remained loyal but still played for herself.
Lisa - HERO. Self explanatory.

CHOROTEGA:
Jeff - HERO. Stood up to Gregg in the first episode, took the fall for being in a different timezone. (This is kind of a stretch.)
Wanda - n/a. Was Wanda ever really relevant? One of the few inconsequential boots.
Caryn - VILLAIN. Bitchy, stand-offish and didn't talk to anyone.
Jolanda - HERO. Hot Tamale! Leader of her alliance, and even though she told people they were going next, she was still a hero IMO.
Gregg - VILLAIN. More of a Tyson-style villain.
Ibe - HERO. Funny and loyal, didn't do anything to piss anyone off.
Tom - HERO. Tom flipped a lot, but I think he was a hero anyways.
Booby Jaundice - VILLAIN. Self explanatory.
Kim - HERO. Played a GREAT game down the middle. Likeable and had a great underdog story.



Here's how I would rank all the villains together and all the heroes together.

VILLAINS:
John
Booby Jaundice
Brook
Mia
Chris
Brook
Gregg

HEROES:
Ami
Kim
Lisa
Ibe
Chad
Jolanda
Tom
Dolly
Jeff

I'm interested to see where Jeff, Helen, and Brenda weigh in on this. And I'd love to hear about Greece/Refuge/Malaysia especially.

I agree with Brenda.
Tom was not a HERO.
I'd have him in the villain list well above atleast 5 of those you suggest Mia.
Me #1 villain. For real? Thanks. I still don't think I was that bad.

I could put in a good argument for Brook being heroic in his actions in trying to stand up for Dolly. Was his flip revenge or retribution like?

Heroic or Idiotic? They're not the same. God love you Brook.
Ultimately, his actions cost him the game. He could have gone alot further.

Mia - VILLAIN. I was ready to turn on Ami pre-merge and Tom early on post-merge. Fought with the Chorotegans/Chad in Ponderosa. Rubbed almost everyone especially original Guatuso the wrong way.
.

I was the hero of Greece.

I didnt know your name was Penny.

It is not.

I was the hero of Greece.

I didnt know your name was Penny.

It is not.

Ok im confused then because you said you were the hero of Greece but your name isnt Penny?

I didnt know your name was Penny.

It is not.

Ok im confused then because you said you were the hero of Greece but your name isnt Penny?

yes

That does not compute. Everyone knows I was the hero of Greece after slaying the evil Helen.

That does not compute. Everyone knows I was the hero of Greece after slaying the evil Helen.

Yes, but I was the one who wanted to slay her all along, not you.

I did so want to slay her all along. But you bitches voted out my slave Daniel and then Erin my BFFL so who the fuck else could I use for votes? Mhmm.

Well, once Rob was gone me and Jo definitely would've taken you to the F3, had you sided with us at F5 :3 And bam you got votes on your side.

Except Penny would have got owned in that f3 lol

You Greece people ruin like every discussion...

Uh, I didn't like any of you in CR.

You were all batshit crazy psychos, it's no wonder I didn't talk to any of you.