Helen Glover wrote:If you do want to make the tribe as dramatic as possible, though, (to at least come close to the shitshow that the other tribe will be) I agree that Jake is non-essential (though very, very kind).
Brenda, can you comment any on if/how Jake has matured as a player since last year?
afaik, Jake hasn't played at all since. He's certainly not played the required five games to get on to Quid's rankings (Greece would have been one). he is a member at ORGY though so he may have played somewhere else - but I don't remember seeing SimonLOTF pop up in any cast reveal ever?
I talked to Jeff about this on AIM, but my two cents here to reiterate;
My number one preference is for Ted to play All-Stars. Because he is.
If however his schedule doesn't allow, then booting Parv is my preference - especially if the tribes are mixed from the start. Punx/BP/KMK/Duck are all mischief-makers already, which ticks that box. However if it's straight-up noobs vs vets, then there is a lack of that type of crazy on the vets side apart from Ted himself so we do need her.
In which case, my preferences run like this;
-MikeyB - but that's more cos I know literally nothing about him, and taking out the Season 9er, puts everyone else from recent Seasons.
-Cut a Grecian - Ken or Jake - would mean one less (Ted is too) but I think Jake brings that good-hearted nature that no-one else really does? If you go this route, we'd lose less if we lost Ken. Plus he's gonna be on the scene for a while I think and more likely to be available for a future Season.
-Cut an Aussie, namely Chase - would be one less Aussie (Ted is too, so are John and Brook but it's hard to have one of those without the other) but Chase really does deserve his spot here maybe more than anyone else?
-Fabio - will be quiet and UTR. Likeable yes, but quiet.
-Jolanda - We have three Costa Ricans. John & Brook depend on each other, that leaves her as the odd one out. Plus, not overly exciting, although I know I'm in the minority on not being a fan.